Choose halts Georgia dredging plan over menace to sea turtles

A federal choose ordered a right away halt on Thursday to plans to dredge a delivery channel on the Georgia coast, citing a menace to sea turtles nesting on close by seashores.

The injunction by U.S. District Choose R. Stan Baker delivered an preliminary setback to the Military Corps of Engineers. The company is attempting to finish a coverage that for 30 years restricted to the winter months the dredging of amassed sand and dirt in harbors from the Carolinas to Florida.

The seasonal limits have been enacted to guard sea turtles from being killed and maimed by the vacuum-like suction pumps of hopper dredges, and conservationists credit score that coverage with serving to threatened and endangered turtles species start to rebound.


Large loggerhead sea turtles, protected as a federally threatened species, nest through the spring and summer time months on seashores from North Carolina to Florida. Smaller numbers of endangered inexperienced and Kemp’s ridley sea turtles lay eggs within the area as properly.

The Military Corps now says the seasonal dredging limits are not essential, citing a report final yr by federal authorities scientists who discovered sea turtles may endure roughly 150 deaths per yr from dredging. The company employed a contractor to begin dredging the delivery channel in Brunswick, Georgia, on Might 28 whereas loggerhead sea turtles have been nesting on close by seashores.

The conservation group One Hundred Miles filed go well with in federal court docket over the proposed shift to year-round dredging. Citing a menace of speedy and irreparable hurt, the group requested the choose to cease the 20-day venture whereas the lawsuit strikes forward.

“There’s a robust chance {that a} substantial and considerable variety of these turtles can be killed by hopper dredging throughout these months,” the choose stated as he dominated within the environmental group’s favor on the shut of a listening to Thursday.

FILE – On this July 5, 2019, file photograph supplied by the Georgia Division of Pure Sources, a loggerhead sea turtle returns to the ocean after nesting on Ossabaw Island, Ga. A federal choose ordered an injunction Thursday, Might 20, 2021, stopping the scheduled dredging of a Georgia delivery channel due to threats to nesting sea turtles. The Military Corps of Engineers desires to scrap a coverage that for 30 years has protected uncommon sea turtles from being mangled and killed by dredged used to suck sediments from harbors in 4 Southern states. (Georgia Division of Pure Sources through AP, File)

The choose ordered the Brunswick dredging venture be placed on maintain till December, until the Corps can use a special sort of dredge that poses far much less threat to sea turtles.

Megan Huynh, an lawyer for the Southern Environmental Legislation Middle, stated a rise in sea turtles killed and mangled by dredges can be a devastating blow for conservationists who’ve volunteered for many years to help their restoration.

Kristofor Swanson, a U.S. authorities lawyer representing the Military Corps, argued the environmentalists failed to indicate there will probably be everlasting hurt if dredging commences on schedule till the lawsuit is resolved. He stated stopping the venture would have financial penalties, as roughly half of ships should wait till greater tides to succeed in the Port of Brunswick, about 70 miles (110 kilometers) south of Savannah.


The Military Corps has stated limiting dredging within the Southeast to a interval that’s roughly between December and March has made it tough to compete for a restricted variety of contractors.

The company additionally argued the seasonal home windows in place since 1991 centered an excessive amount of on sea turtles, whereas ignoring different protected species corresponding to critically endangered North Atlantic proper whales that frequent the identical waters throughout winter.

However the choose cited the longevity of these seasonal limits as proof that year-round dredging may imperil numerous sea turtles.

“Frankly it’s a stretch to consider the Corps would have abstained from spring and summer time dredging within the space for many years if it didn’t consider there was a major hazard to loggerhead sea turtles throughout that point,” Baker stated.

A spokeswoman for the Military Corps’ Savannah District didn’t instantly return an e-mail message searching for touch upon the choose’s choice.

Mark Dodd, a wildlife biologist who oversees the ocean turtle restoration program for the Georgia Division of Pure Sources, advised the choose that dredging in Charleston, South Carolina, not too long ago killed 5 sea turtles in a single day.

Dodd stated a September 2009 trial run at dredging exterior the seasonal home windows in Georgia was rapidly scrapped after dredges killed six loggerhead turtles in Brunswick and Savannah inside 15 days of dredging.


“It confirmed that the captured fee for turtles was eight occasions greater than it’s within the winter on common,” Dodd stated. “That was a take stage that was thought-about to be unacceptably excessive. The venture was shut down.”

The choose additionally sided with the conservation group to find that the Military Corps violated the Nationwide Environmental Coverage Act by transferring forward with its dredging plan with out conducting a examine of the anticipate environmental impacts to sea turtles and different species.

“There’s a public curiosity in and of itself for holding governmental companies accountable for failing to adjust to authorities rules,” Baker stated.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *